Even in this era of technology, still, some people love mechanical sewing machines. The majority of the users of mechanical sewing machines are those who switch from a vintage sewing machine.
They find the controls of a computerized sewing machine too complicated to learn. A mechanical sewing machine is the best option then. Mechanical sewing machines tend to last longer than computerized ones.
Moreover, you can save a lot of dollars on repair costs, as the parts of mechanical sewing machines are very cheap when compared to the electronic components of a computerized sewing machine.
The frustrating thing about computerized sewing machines is that there are a lot of electronic parts to go wrong, and only a trained professional will be able to fix it.
On the other hand, you can try some self-repair techniques on a mechanical sewing machine even if you are not experienced in repairing sewing machines.
The durability factor was the main selling point of mechanical sewing machines 100 years ago, and still, it is. Some things like this never change with time. So is your mom’s love.
Reviews of the Mechanical Sewing Machines 2020 – (Editors’ Choice)
Now let us have a look at the best mechanical sewing machines you can get in the U.S. There are few in the market, but you need to choose the one that has quality.
Cheap ones are not recommended as they will misbehave at some point. This list is created by taking 2 points into account; they are listed in the order of priority
- Quality of performance
- User feedback
It was a daunting task to come up with a list like this. I reviewed over 30 machines, and after days of filtering, I came up with the list of 7 top mechanical sewing machines that can provide value for the money spent.
1. Janome HD3000
This is the ideal mechanical sewing machine. This is one of the expensive machines on my list. No other machine can handle heavy-duty fabrics better than this one.
It has 18 built-in stitches, automatic needle threader, and a built-in thread cutter. This is a costly machine for sure, but if you are a person who loves quality more than the low price, you should consider this.
I am a big fan of this machine, just because of the quality of stitches it can provide, especially while sewing denim and other heavy-duty fabrics. Being a heavy model, it is much heavier than other machines.
Most parts are made of metal, and so durability won’t be an issue at all. A sturdy workhorse by all means.
The built-in sewing light needs to be better. You can’t rely on it; you need exterior lighting. For the price, Janome could have included at least a dozen extra built-in stitches. It seems Janome has focused more on quality than on features.
2. Singer 4423
Its popularity is because it is heavy-duty and is inexpensive. The stitch quality is not bad as well. It has 23 built-in stitches, automatic needle threader, a drop-in bobbin, and a 1-step buttonhole.
Even though 4423 is a heavy-duty model, don’t expect this to run over eight-plus layers of denim. That will be asking too much from a machine of this price.
3. Janome 2212
Janome 2212 retains the 4th posture not due to the attributes, but thanks to the standard of stitches. The user feedback for this equipment is unimaginable for the stitching device that does not give you a lot regarding features.
It has 12 built-in stitches, including a 4-step buttonhole. The quality of the stitches is excellent, and it works well with multiple layers of denim. It is a sturdy machine; you can expect this machine to last for years.
The main disadvantage of this machine is the lack of features, especially when you consider the price. It does not have a self-acting needle threaded or a drop-in bobbin or a 1-step buttonhole. These features are vital for a beginner sewer. It does not have a lot of stitch options as well.
4. Brother XL-3750
Another low-cost wonder from Brother and that too, with impressive features. You can say that it is feature-rich for the price. It comes with 35 built-in stitches, automatic needle threader, a drop-in bobbin, and a 1-step buttonhole.
It is an incredibly light sewing machine, so it will be handy for those who are attending sewing classes. It sews through heavy fabrics quite well, provided you have the right needle in place.
Sometimes the tension is off; once fixed, it doesn’t reappear for a while. The built-in sewing light is very dim for my liking.
5. Janome HD1000
HD1000 is the younger brother of HD3000, with lesser features and lesser price. If you can’t afford HD3000, then the next best option is this one.
The construction is almost identical. HD1000 has 14 built-in stitches and a 4-step buttonhole. Like HD3000, this is also a solid performer. It won’t struggle with multiple layers of thick fabrics. The consistency of the stitches is impressive.
After HD3000, it is the second-best heavy-duty sewing machine, but it lacks some features that beginners love, like the 1-step buttonhole and drop-in bobbin.
6. Janome 2206
This is the minimum pricey Janome equipment during this listing. Like 2212 model, 2206 also grew to become common by way of mouth publicity.
It does not have a lot of features to boast of, but it does what it is supposed to do. It sews well with consistent stitch quality. It comes with six built-in stitches, a 4-step buttonhole, and a built-in thread cutter.
Similar to 2212, this one also lacks features like an automatic needle threader, drop-in bobbin, and a 1-step buttonhole.
7. Brother XL2600I
This is the king of low-cost sewing machines. If you are under a budget and you don’t want to compromise too much on quality, then Brother XL2600I will be a good option.
It has been the best seller in the price category for quite a while now. It is the least expensive sewing machine on this list. Even though it is cheap, it still has some excellent features, including 25 built-in stitches, automatic needle threader, 1-step buttonhole, drop-in bobbin, etc.
Being a cheap sewing machine, you can’t expect it to be good at multiple sewing layers of thick fabrics like denim. The overall stitch quality is not bad, though. The user manual also requires some improvement. It is not that easy to understand.
Are You Looking For Mechanical Sewing Machine? Here’s What You Need to Consider
A lot of people prefer to purchase a mechanical machine for their sewing needs over a computerized or electronic variant. There are lots of reasons behind their choice of this machine.
One of the common reasons is the price factor as these are much lesser than the others. Moreover, they are also easy to maintain and can last a long time with people who are into sewing.
The money spent on maintaining a mechanical machine is a lot lesser when compared to its variants. Oiling it regularly and keeping it clean would be adequate in most cases for these machines. Servicing it at regular intervals is also easier and does not require professional help.
However, once you have decided to purchase a machine-driven device for your sewing needs you may have to consider a few things. We have tallied some of the prominent aspects that you ought to look at before investing in one of these machines.
Ease of Operating
One of the aspects that you would have to take notice of the ease at which you can operate the machine. Although a mechanical machine is simpler for your stitching there are ones in the market that are a little complex too.
Ideally, you would have to select a machine that matches your level of expertise. This would ensure that you can create pieces of excellence with fabric once you put them to use.
Weight and Budget
Sewing machines that are machine-driven are lighter in weight when compared to their variants like electronic or computerized. This is because they do not have a computer inside the machine.
Purchasing a machine that is light in weight can do wonders for you. However, you might not want to compromise on the parts of the machine that might not be in metal. Metal parts last longer than their plastic counterparts.
Keeping a budget separately for a mechanical sewing machine should also be of prominence. Purchasing one that is too costly may end up being a complex machine.
On the alternative, investing too little would mean that you purchase a machine with fragile plastic parts. You would ideally be able to hit the balance between the two.
Doing a Trial Run
Taking a fabric along with you while you go for a purchase may be a good idea. This would allow you to try the machine if possible and try some of the important patterns that you wish to do on the mechanical machine.
In case you are purchasing it online, it would be a great idea to read reviews and testimonials before you do. It can give you an idea of how good the machine is for sewing with different fabrics and patterns.
Accessories and Compatibility
Usually, mechanical machines for sewing might not come with a lot of accessories. However, you might want to check if they are compatible for them to accommodate different accessories that you can purchase from the market. This is one important thing that many people miss out on.
Purchase from a Local Manufacturer
Purchasing a mechanical machine would be a good idea if you do so from a local manufacturer. This is because your servicing and maintenance needs would be met with a good response if the machine is locally manufactured.
In the case of a product that is made by a foreign company, the chances are that you might not get the type of service and support that you expect.
Last but not least of the aspects that you would have to look at is the features. The simpler the features on the mechanical machine the easier it would be for you to operate and maintain.
It would also allow you to do different types of manual stitches with it than the more complex ones. Although it may increase your workload it would give you a better finish to your completed stitching project.
What is the difference between Mechanical and Electronic Sewing Machines?
If you are trying to figure out the differences between Mechanical and Electronic Sewing Machines, we will get you a clear picture of the differences. Besides explaining the differences between mechanical and electronic sewing machines, we have also shared the best known mechanical and electronic machines to help you with a faster choice.
In a mechanical sewing machine, a user has to do many things manually, from positioning the needle, stitch selection, to moving the knobs and lever. Mechanical sewing machines are ideal for beginners, and if you are about to buy one, you have to make sure that it has the following features:
- built-in presser feet,
- bottom loading bobbin,
- adjustable stitch length, and tension,
- reverse stitch.
On the contrary, an electronic sewing machine comes with comparatively better and easy control with push buttons, menu settings on LCD, computerized control of stitch selection, stitch length, and width, pre-loaded sewing patterns. However, these sewing machines are comparatively more expensive than mechanical sewing machines.
Another critical difference is in terms of the number of in-built stitches. While mechanical sewing machines come with a very limited number of stitches, electronic sewing machines come with various in-built stitches.
Electronic Sewing machines can also be seen as a blend of mechanical and electronic components. You can surely save much time by using an electronic machine since unlike a mechanical machine, an automatic machine comes with several automatic features that include:
- Auto bobbin winder,
- Automatic thread cutter,
- Automatic tension adjustment,
- Straight stitch function
However, you have a couple of advantages with mechanical sewing machines. These machines are pretty simple, which is why they don’t require any repairs or maintenance much often.
On the contrary, just as any electronic product is, an electronic sewing machine may need maintenance more often than a mechanical machine.
It is because an electronic sewing machine has a lot of electronic components, and while one component is working fine, another may stop functioning at some point and need repairs.
Cloth Material and Projects
Mechanical sewing machines can be used to sew just any cloth material except for leather and denim. An electronic machine is ideal for various projects that may include DIY, textiles, and hobby projects.
Most importantly, since most electronic sewing machines come with a powerful motor, they allow you to sew through thicker materials such as Leather and Denim quickly.
Some Good Mechanical Sewing Machines
- Brother XR3774
- Singer 3232
- Singer Heavy Duty 4423
- Singer Heavy Duty 4452
- Brother XM2701
Some Good Electronic Sewing Machines
- SINGER 9985 Quantum Stylist TOUCH
- SINGER 9960 Quantum Stylist
- Brother Project Runway CS5055PRW
- SINGER 8763
- Brother cs6000i
Top-rated Mechanical Sewing Machines Comparison Chart
|Model||Stitches||Drop-in Bobbin||Auto Needle threader||Stitches|
|Janome HD3000||18||Yes||Yes||860||16 x 11.3 x 7.2 inches|
|SINGER 4423||23||Yes||Yes||1100||15.5 x 6.2 x 12 inches|
|Janome 2212||12||Yes||Yes||860||17x 19 x 13.5 inches|
|Brother XL-3750||35||Yes||Yes||800||15.4 x 6.7 x 11.5 inches|
|Janome HD1000||14||Yes||Yes||860||18.25 x 8.5 x 15.25 inches|
|Janome 2206||6||Yes||Yes||860||15.2 x 11.6 x 6 inches|
|Brother XL2600I||25||Yes||Yes||800||12.3 x 7.7 x 9.6 inches|
This concludes my list of 7 Best Mechanical Sewing Machines. I hope this list will help you make a decision. Here are my final recommendations
- Go for Janome HD3000, if you sew a lot and want a heavy-duty machine that is easy to use.
- Go for Brother XL2600I or Brother XL-3750 if you want a lot of features, and you are on a budget.